Instant Plumbing Logo Calgary Plumbers



Do Water Softener Shower Heads Work?

A water softener shower head

As water softener experts, we occasionally come across questions about whether Water Softener shower heads actually work.

We reluctantly say that they do, kind of… for a short period, and they are not a match for having a water softener unit installed in your home, let’s dive deeper.

Introduction to Water Softener Shower Heads

Water quality in our homes, especially in showers, is a concern that often goes unnoticed. While many turn to water softener shower heads as a quick fix, it’s essential to understand their capabilities and limitations. These devices are designed to tackle hard water problems, primarily by reducing mineral content that can harm skin and hair. However, are they the best solution available?

The Purpose of Water Softener Shower Heads

Water softener shower heads aim to mitigate the effects of hard water by filtering out minerals and balancing the water’s pH levels. This can lead to improved skin and hair health, as hard water is known to cause dryness and irritation.

These shower heads work by introducing filtering agents that capture minerals like calcium and magnesium, which are responsible for water hardness. While they offer a localized solution, their scope and effectiveness are limited compared to whole-house water softening systems.

Effectiveness of Water Softener Shower Heads

The effectiveness of water softener shower heads is a topic of debate. While they can provide temporary relief from hard water, their impact is often superficial and short-lived. These devices are not designed to handle the high mineral content effectively over a long period. Moreover, the quality of these shower heads varies significantly, and maintenance can be frequent and costly. In contrast, whole-house water softeners offer a more comprehensive and long-term solution.

By treating water at its source, these systems ensure that all water in the home, not just in the shower, is softened. This approach is far more effective in dealing with hard water issues throughout the house.

Mechanism: How Water is Softened in Showers

Water softener shower heads typically use filters made of carbon or other materials to trap minerals. However, this process is limited to the water that passes through the shower head, leaving the rest of the home’s water untreated. In contrast, a whole-house water softener system treats water at its entry point into the home, ensuring that all water, whether for showering, cooking, or cleaning, is softened.

This not only improves the quality of the water for bathing but also extends the life of appliances and plumbing by preventing scale buildup. Whole-house systems use more sophisticated technologies like ion exchange or reverse osmosis, offering a more thorough and lasting solution to hard water problems.

Why we recommend whole-house softeners vs shower-head softeners

Choosing a whole-house water softener over a shower head water softener offers several significant advantages:

  1. Comprehensive Water Treatment: A whole-house water softener treats all the water entering your home, not just the water in your shower. This means that the benefits of softened water extend to your kitchen, laundry, and all other water fixtures. It ensures that all the water you use for drinking, cooking, bathing, and cleaning is free from the hard minerals that can cause problems.
  2. Protection for Appliances and Plumbing: Hard water can cause limescale buildup in pipes and appliances, leading to reduced efficiency and potentially costly repairs. A whole-house water softener prevents this buildup, extending the life of your plumbing system and appliances like washing machines, dishwashers, and water heaters.
  3. Better Skin and Hair Health: While a shower head water softener can improve the quality of water for your shower, a whole-house system ensures that all the water you use for bathing is soft. This can lead to healthier skin and hair, as soft water is better at rinsing away soap and shampoo, which reduces dryness, irritation, and buildup.
  4. Improved Cleaning Efficiency: Soft water enhances the effectiveness of soaps and detergents. This means you’ll need less soap for bathing, less detergent for laundry, and fewer cleaning agents for household chores, leading to cost savings and a reduced environmental footprint.
  5. Consistent Water Quality: Shower head water softeners can vary in their effectiveness and often require frequent maintenance and filter changes. A whole-house system provides a consistent level of water softening with less frequent maintenance needs.
  6. Long-Term Cost Savings: Although the initial investment for a whole-house water softener is higher than a shower head model, the long-term savings can be significant. Reduced scale buildup means fewer plumbing issues and lower appliance repair costs. Additionally, the efficiency in soap and detergent usage can also lead to cost savings over time.
  7. Improved Water Taste and Quality: For those sensitive to the taste of hard water, a whole-house water softener can improve the overall taste and quality of the water, making it more pleasant for drinking and cooking.

In summary, while shower head water softeners are a more budget-friendly and straightforward solution, they offer limited benefits compared to whole-house systems. If you’re looking for a comprehensive solution to hard water problems in your home, a whole-house water softener is the more effective choice.


  1. Do shower head water softeners really soften water? Shower head filters primarily remove chlorine and some scale but don’t change the hardness of the water significantly. For true water softening, a whole-house system is recommended.
  2. How often do whole-house water softeners need maintenance? Maintenance frequency varies, but ion-exchange softeners typically require salt replenishment every few months, while reverse osmosis filters might need annual replacement.
  3. Can a water softener improve skin and hair health? Yes, soft water can significantly improve skin and hair health by reducing the harsh effects of hard water, like dryness and irritation.
  4. Is it worth installing a whole-house water softener? Considering the comprehensive benefits for the entire home, including prolonged appliance life, improved water quality, and better skin and hair health, a whole-house water softener is a valuable investment.
  5. Do I still need a shower filter if I have a whole-house softener? Generally, a whole-house softener negates the need for additional shower filters, as it treats all the water entering your home.


George Pinel
George Pinel

Master Plumber

I have been involved in this family owned business for 33 years now.

It has always been and will continue to be the core focus of Instant Plumbing & Heating to provide a long lasting relationship with our customers based on trust and integrity of our service and products.

This achieved by using the best quality materials. I as a business owner continue to mentor and treat my staff with the highest regard and respect, this interns helps them deliver to the client great quality workmanship and service.

It is our professional goal to leave a situation better than when we arrived both in how we do our work and in how you feel for having chosen us to do your work, we are in the anxiety reduction business using plumbing and heating service work to do it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Social media


For evening, weekend or holiday service, please call (403) 338-1172.